Blog/ Pebble vs. Quartz vs. Plaster
If your pool is starting to feel a little 2008—etched steps, mottled color, and stains that never quite brush out—resurfacing is the glow-up that changes everything. In Wylie and across North Texas, we’re seeing clear favorites in 2026: modern pebbles, refined quartz blends, and a smarter take on classic plaster. Here’s how to pick the finish that fits your style, your budget, and our local water.
Ready for options with real samples? Start here: Pool Remodeling. Considering a trim refresh too? See Tile & Coping Updates below.
Pebble (mini/polished): Most durable, textured, “natural lagoon” to modern look, widest color range.
Quartz: Smooth feel, richer color than plaster, great value + longevity.
Plaster (white or tinted): Lowest upfront cost, classic hotel-blue look, shortest lifespan.
The heavy, dark pebble boom is giving way to mini-pebble and polished pebble blends in coastal light tones (think Tahoe, French gray, and soft graphite).
Why homeowners love it
Durability: Pebble stones resist etching and spotty chemistry better than plain plaster.
Depth drama: Lighter pebble on shelves and steps with a slightly deeper hue in the well gives you a custom gradient without a custom price.
Texture choice: Mini-pebble = finer feel underfoot; polished pebble = surprisingly smooth, spa-like surface that still wears like stone.
Best for: Families who want years of use with minimal cosmetic wear, and anyone who entertains at night with LED lighting (pebble catches light beautifully).
Quartz finishes are the 2026 value hero—smoother than pebble, stronger than plaster.
Color stability: Quartz aggregates help maintain tone even with high sun and occasional chemistry swings.
Silky feel: Great for kids and frequent swimmers.
Budget-friendly: Most clients land here when they want “premium without the premium.”
Best for: Homeowners who want a modern, refined look that outlasts plaster but don’t need the ultra-long lifespan of pebble.
Plaster is still alive—and better—when expectations are set correctly.
Lower upfront cost and that classic bright-blue, resort vibe.
Looks amazing day one, but it requires disciplined start-up and maintenance to stay pretty.
Tinted options (light gray, aqua) are trending to hide mottling better than pure white.
Best for: Budget-conscious refreshes, homes planning to sell, or clients who like to resurface more frequently to change the look.
Finish base: White bases read blue; gray bases read modern/steel blue; tan bases read tropical/teal.
Aggregate type: Quartz fleck adds shimmer; pebble mix adds texture and dimensionality.
Depth + sun angle: Shallow steps will always look lighter; deep ends and overcast days read darker.
Tile line: A modern matte porcelain at the waterline instantly elevates the look—and can shift how your eye reads the water tone.
Want the facelift without a full gut? Pair your interior with Tile & Coping Updates for a big visual jump on a reasonable spend.
| Finish | Typical Lifespan* | Feel | Upfront Cost | Care Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pebble (mini/polished) | 15–20+ yrs | Textured → Smooth (polished) | $$$ | Extremely durable; forgiving of minor chemistry swings |
| Quartz | 10–15 yrs | Smooth | $$ | Keep calcium balanced to prevent scale; great color retention |
| Plaster | 7–10 yrs | Smooth | $ | Most sensitive to pH/alk swings; expect mottling over time |
*Assumes professional start-up, balanced chemistry, and regular brushing.
Exact numbers depend on pool size, prep work, and local material pricing, but here’s how to think about budget tiers for a typical Wylie backyard pool:
Plaster: $ — Lowest entry cost. Add 10–20% if you choose a tinted color, and budget for more attentive chemistry to preserve the look.
Quartz: $$ — Mid-tier. Often the best value when you want a smoother surface with stronger color that lasts notably longer than plaster.
Pebble (mini/polished): $$$ — Highest upfront, lowest long-term fuss. Mini-pebble usually prices under polished pebble; polished adds labor but achieves a very smooth feel with stone durability.
High-impact add-ons that move the needle (and are worth it):
Waterline tile replacement (you’re draining anyway)
Coping refresh (travertine or precast for a clean edge)
LED lighting (energy-efficient + night ambiance)
Pad tidy/re-plumb (future-proofs maintenance and upgrades)
Bundling these while the pool is empty cuts repeat mobilizations and speeds the project.
The first 30–60 days make or break any new surface. We handle start-up for you, but here’s what the process looks like behind the scenes so you know your investment is protected.
Day 1–3: Fill + first tests
Fill without interruption to avoid “bathtub ring” lines.
Begin circulation and test pH, alkalinity, calcium hardness, and chlorine. pH will trend up—this is normal as the surface cures.
Day 4–14: Daily brushing + gentle chemistry
Brush walls, steps, and benches 1–2× daily to move dust and even the cure.
Keep pH in range; avoid big swings. Add chlorine conservatively; no salt cell yet.
Day 15–30: Stabilize
Introduce stabilizer (CYA) gradually.
Consider a sequestering agent if your fill water is mineral-rich (common in North Texas).
For salt systems, we wait until the surface is ready before bringing the cell online at low output.
Day 30–60: Set the rhythm
Dial in calcium hardness to protect from etching (too low) or scaling (too high).
Adjust pump schedules for circulation at your preferred swim temp.
Keep brushing weekly; quartz and pebble need less over time, plaster appreciates the attention.
We include professional start-up and hands-on coaching after every resurface so the finish cures right—and stays beautiful.
30+ years resurfacing in North Texas
Curated finishes proven in our sun and water
Professional start-up so your surface cures correctly
Design-build coordination if you’re updating tile, coping, lighting, or the equipment pad
Let’s bring back the “wow” every time you open the back door.
Start your options tour: Pool Remodeling · Tile & Coping Updates
Mini-pebble is remarkably comfortable; polished pebble is the smoothest stone option if you want that spa feel.
It resists staining far better than plaster. Balanced chemistry and occasional brushing keep it pristine.
Usually a few days after fill, with a brushing/chemistry plan. We’ll give you the exact timeline at install.
Yes, but it’s more efficient (and often cheaper) to update them while the pool is empty for resurfacing.
Slightly—but circulation and shade matter more. We’ll help you balance tone, temperature, and the look you want.